Home » The Profit First Construction Field Guide » Pricing and bidding with Profit First

Profit First for Construction FAQ

Pricing and bidding with Profit First

A job priced only to cover its costs can still starve the business, so these answers start at the bid.

Related topics:Job costing: JobEx and OpExBilling, WIP, and retainage

Pricing jobs so they fund the business

How should retainage affect my bidding and pricing?

The short answer

Retainage is a cash-timing and working-capital issue, not a reason to change your Profit First allocation targets; if delayed retainage creates a real financing burden on a specific job, reflect that cost in the bid price, payment terms, or billing strategy rather than adjusting your allocation percentages.

Why it’s different in construction

An electrical contractor running close to 100 employees on commercial work may carry retainage for six to eighteen months on a single project, which ties up real working capital. That carrying cost (interest on a line of credit, opportunity cost, or the risk of an owner dispute) is a legitimate job expense, and it belongs in the bid. The right place to address it is in pricing and contract terms: negotiate shorter retainage periods, milestone-based retainage reductions, or front-loaded billing where the contract allows. What it should never do is trigger a change to your Profit First allocation percentages mid-project or mid-quarter, because retainage does not change the underlying economics of how you split revenue across your accounts.

From the field

An electrical contractor with about 85 employees had been winning competitive commercial bids for years but noticed that cash always felt tight even on jobs that looked profitable. A closer look revealed that the company was carrying several hundred thousand dollars in unreleased retainage across four active jobs at any given time, and the owner had never factored the financing cost of that float into the bids. After working through Profit First for Construction, the owner started treating retainage timing as a real cost in the estimating process, adding it to the job’s working-capital analysis before submitting a number. On the next two large bids, the owner also negotiated a retainage reduction clause at 50% completion, which cut the average holdback period by about three months. Within a year, the chronic line-of-credit balance dropped by roughly $180,000 because the jobs were priced and structured to carry themselves.

Where people get it wrong

A common piece of advice is to raise your Profit or POT allocation percentage to ‘compensate’ for retainage. That misunderstands what retainage is. Retainage does not reduce your profit margin: it delays when you receive cash you have already earned. Raising an allocation percentage does not solve a timing problem; it just reshuffles the same dollars. The right fix is in the bid price and contract terms, not in the allocation structure.

In the book: Profit First for Commercial Construction, Chapter 13, Building Resilience: Cash Flow Management in Uncertain Times.

How does separating JobEx and OpEx help me price my bids?

The short answer

Separating JobEx from OpEx shows you exactly how much of every dollar of revenue is consumed by direct job costs versus the overhead required to keep the business running, so you can price work that genuinely supports Owner’s Compensation, Tax, and Profit, not just break even on the job itself.

Why it’s different in construction

Construction bids are built from the bottom up (materials, subs, equipment rentals, bonds, permits), but overhead and profit are often added as a gut-feel percentage rather than a number grounded in the business’s actual cost structure. When you calculate your CAPs from twelve months of real numbers, you can see whether your current pricing even covers OpEx before a dollar reaches Profit or Owner’s Comp. That clarity changes how you evaluate a low-margin job: it’s not just thin on paper, it’s actively pulling cash away from overhead and your own pay.

From the field

A husband-and-wife general contracting shop with a small crew had been winning work steadily for years but couldn’t figure out why the bank account never grew. They priced jobs the way they’d always been taught: estimate materials and subs, add a markup, hope for the best. When they built their CAPs for the first time, they discovered their combined JobEx and OpEx percentages exceeded 100% of revenue on most jobs. They weren’t pricing in enough margin to cover overhead at all, let alone pay themselves consistently. Over the next two quarters they repriced their standard scope packages using their actual OpEx number as a floor, declined two jobs that couldn’t support it, and picked up one job at a higher price than they’d ever quoted before, and got it. Within six months Owner’s Comp was funded every allocation cycle without a scramble.

From the book, Chapter 16, p. 239

“I never really understood our overhead—at least, not in a practical way. For the first time, I have a system to track it and cash I can count on. It’s helped me bid jobs right. I’ve got a whole new perspective.”

Profit First for Commercial Construction

Where people get it wrong

A persistent myth in construction is that overhead is a standard trade or regional percentage you can look up and plug into a bid. Your overhead is unique to your business: your office rent, your insurance, your admin staff, your truck payments. Using someone else’s benchmark means you may be systematically underpricing every job you win. Build your OpEx percentage from your own twelve months of actual numbers, and use that as your floor when you price.

In the book: Profit First for Commercial Construction, Chapter 5, Overhead Uncovered: A Cash Flow Perspective.

If a GC is paying me net-60 with retainage but my subs need net-30, how does my bid protect me?

The short answer

When your subs must be paid before the GC pays you, the working-capital gap and its financing cost are real expenses: quantify them and reflect a material cost in your bid or negotiate payment terms, rather than absorbing the gap silently.

Why it’s different in construction

This timing mismatch is one of the most common cash traps in commercial construction. Paying subs 30 days before the GC pays you is like fronting the float on someone else’s credit card: the convenience is theirs, and the interest is yours. On a large job with retainage on top of net-60 terms, that gap can run well into six figures. The cost of carrying it, whether you’re drawing on a line of credit or tying up your own cash, is a real cost of doing the job, and it belongs in the price. Where possible, negotiate up-front payments or deposits to reduce how much of that gap you have to finance yourself.

From the field

A glass and glazing contractor with about 15 employees kept winning commercial jobs but felt like he was always scrambling for cash mid-project. He was paying his specialty subs every 30 days while the GC paid him on net-60 terms, with 10% held until final completion. On a $900,000 curtain-wall job, he was routinely carrying $80,000 to $100,000 in unpaid receivables while his sub invoices kept coming due. He had never built that financing cost into his bids; he just assumed it was part of doing business. After mapping out the timing gap on his next three bids and adding a line for carrying cost, his margins improved noticeably. He also started asking GCs for a mobilization payment on jobs over $500,000, and two out of three said yes.

From the book, Chapter 9, p. 155

“These owners think we are the bank for them!” Mark scoffed. “One positive thing to come out of the supply chain issues is that many contractors have learned to ask for money up front, especially on these cost-plus jobs, and they’re not as shy about it. Whenever possible, stop being your client’s finance company and ask for payment in advance. Sometimes it is easier to justify when you explain, like Paul did, that their job will be delayed without it because you can’t order the materials.” “Can I get an amen?” Alex piped up. “Requesting money up front definitely helps with cash flow,” I said, “and if you can’t float the materials, you shouldn’t rely on lines of credit.

Profit First for Commercial Construction

Where people get it wrong

Some contractors assume the right fix is to draw on a line of credit whenever subs need to be paid. A line of credit can cover a short timing gap in a pinch, but it’s a last resort, not an operating account and not a substitute for pricing the job correctly. Relying on a revolving credit line to fund routine sub payments means you’re paying interest on a problem that belongs in your bid.

In the book: Profit First for Commercial Construction, Chapter 9, Creating Clarity: Considering Your Banking Needs.

How do I measure the cash overhead I need to support when pricing work?

The short answer

Measuring cash overhead for pricing means starting with your actual cash operating costs, not just what the P&L shows, by removing noncash items where appropriate and adding back cash obligations like principal debt payments that never appear as an expense. Profit First for Construction doesn’t give you a benchmark percentage; it asks you to build the number from your own business.

Why it’s different in construction

Mechanical and HVAC contractors often carry equipment loans, vehicle notes, and lease obligations that show up as balance sheet items rather than P&L expenses, which means a standard income statement understates the cash the business actually needs to survive. If you price work based only on what the P&L calls overhead, you’re leaving those cash obligations uncovered. Seasonality adds another wrinkle: your overhead runs year-round, but revenue may be heavier in certain months, so the annual cash overhead figure needs to inform pricing even in slower periods.

From the field

An HVAC and mechanical contractor with eight employees had been using a rough overhead percentage he’d picked up at a trade association seminar years earlier. It seemed reasonable, and his bids were competitive, but he was always thin on cash by mid-year. When he sat down and built his actual cash overhead figure (pulling twelve months of bank statements, adding back principal payments on two equipment loans, and stripping out depreciation), the number came out meaningfully higher than what he’d been using. He’d been underpricing work for years without knowing it. He adjusted his markup on the next round of bids, lost one job he probably would have lost money on anyway, and ended the year with his OpEx account actually covering what it needed to cover.

From the book, Chapter 5, p. 95

Those monthly or sometimes weekly payments on your truck notes or equipment come out in cash but aren’t reflected on the P&L.” “I see where you’re going with this now,” Alex said. “The interest is included in that note payment, right?” “Exactly. Remember, we are looking at what happened to your cash,” I said. […] “I see why you said my equipment payments go in there now,” Elvis said. “I get why you said that I have those payments whether I have a job or not.”

Profit First for Commercial Construction

Where people get it wrong

One of the most common mistakes I see is contractors using an industry overhead percentage from a trade publication or consultant and plugging it straight into their estimates. Using someone else’s overhead percentage to price your work is like wearing a stranger’s prescription glasses: it might be close enough to get around, but you’re still going to run into things. Your overhead is yours: it depends on your headcount, your debt load, your shop, your trucks, and your market. A percentage that fits a ten-person shop in one city may be completely wrong for yours. Build the number from your own cash reality, then use it to price.

In the book: Profit First for Commercial Construction, Chapter 5, Overhead Uncovered: A Cash Flow Perspective.

How should Profit First influence my estimating and bidding?

The short answer

Profit First for Construction changes bidding by anchoring every estimate to your actual JobEx and OpEx economics, so you can test whether a proposed price will support the business before you sign the contract, not after the job is done.

Why it’s different in construction

Construction bids often carry retainage holdbacks, long payment terms, and front-loaded material costs that create real financing drag. If those contract terms create a material cost to your cash flow, build that economic cost into the bid price itself rather than trying to compensate by adjusting your Profit First allocation targets later. After an acquisition or a major crew change, use actual post-transition job results to sharpen future estimates rather than relying on the prior owner’s numbers, which may not reflect your real cost structure.

From the field

A general contractor approaching 100 employees had been winning plenty of work but couldn’t figure out why the bank account never grew. When we pulled apart the numbers, it turned out the estimating team was pricing jobs based on gut feel and prior-year averages, with no connection to what the business actually needed to cover JobEx, OpEx, and a real owner’s wage. They were winning bids that looked fine on paper but couldn’t support the overhead that came with running 90-plus people. Over about two quarters, we rebuilt the estimating process around their actual cost structure. Bids that didn’t pencil out at the right economics either got repriced, rescoped, or passed on. Within six months the owner had declined three jobs he would previously have chased, and the business was more profitable than it had been in years.

From the book, Chapter 14, pp. 215 to 216

“That you have naturally developed some percentages to use when you bid your jobs,” I said. “And you now bid for profit, in cash, and not from a financial statement approach. When you can capitalize on that, you’ll really start to develop profit in your business.”

Profit First for Commercial Construction

Where people get it wrong

A common mistake is treating Profit First allocations as a markup formula, just adding a fixed profit percentage on top of estimated costs. Treating your allocation targets as a markup formula is like using a budget to set a price: the budget tells you what the business needs to survive, but the market doesn’t care what you need. The allocations tell you what the business needs to survive and grow; if the market price for a job can’t support those needs, the answer is to fix the scope, the costs, or the price, not to lower your targets and hope for the best.

In the book: Profit First for Commercial Construction, Chapter 5, Overhead Uncovered: A Cash Flow Perspective.

How do I use CAPs to make decisions about pricing and job selection?

The short answer

CAPs (Current Allocation Percentages) show you exactly where every dollar of revenue is going today (to JobEx, OpEx, and what’s left over), so you can see whether your pricing actually leaves enough for Owner’s Compensation, Profit, and Tax, and use that reality to sharpen your bids and choose better jobs.

Why it’s different in construction

Steel erection and other specialty trades carry heavy JobEx: crews, equipment rentals, bonds, and subs can easily consume a large share of the contract value. When you calculate your CAPs from your own 12-month numbers, you may find that JobEx and OpEx together are eating so much of revenue that Residual Revenue is razor thin. It’s like running a job-cost report mid-project and discovering you’ve already spent nearly every dollar before you’ve touched overhead or profit, except CAPs show you that pattern across your whole business, not just one job. That gap tells you whether your current bid prices are structurally too low, whether a particular job type is chronically unprofitable, or whether overhead has crept up faster than volume.

From the field

A steel erection sub with roughly 60 employees had been winning plenty of work but never seemed to get ahead. When the owner sat down and calculated his CAPs for the first time, he could see that JobEx and OpEx together were consuming nearly everything coming in, leaving almost nothing for his own pay, taxes, or any profit. He realized he had been pricing jobs based on what he thought the market would bear rather than what his own cost structure required. Over the next two bid cycles he raised his prices on the job types where his margins were worst, declined two projects that his CAPs analysis flagged as near-breakeven, and redirected capacity toward work where his crew was most efficient. Within two quarters his Residual Revenue had improved meaningfully and he was consistently funding all six accounts.

From the book, Chapter 5, p. 96

“What if I can’t get those prices from my customers?” Elvis asked. “I won’t get the jobs.” “Then at least you know what the jobs cost you in cash,” I said. “True,” Alex said. “But what if I want to do better than those percentages? Can I use them to set targets and improve?”

Profit First for Commercial Construction

Where people get it wrong

A common mistake is using industry or trade benchmark percentages to set targets instead of building CAPs from your own numbers. Benchmarks describe someone else’s business. Your CAPs reflect your actual crew mix, your equipment situation, your market, and your overhead, and those are the numbers that have to work for you.

In the book: Profit First for Commercial Construction, Chapter 6, Setting Targets: Knowing What to Shoot For.

How can an estimating worksheet help me avoid underbidding?

The short answer

An estimating worksheet helps you avoid underbidding by working backward from your Profit First allocation targets: start with realistic direct job costs, determine the margin the job must leave after JobEx, and solve for the revenue and markup that actually support the business, not just cover the work.

Why it’s different in construction

Masonry and other trade contractors often carry significant material costs and subcontractor labor that vary job to job, making it easy to underestimate JobEx on a tight bid. The worksheet forces you to separate what the job will actually consume in cash (materials, subs, bonds, permits, and any equipment rented specifically for that job) from the overhead the business carries regardless. If the estimated price won’t leave enough after JobEx to fund OpEx, Owner’s Comp, Profit, and Tax at their target percentages, you either raise the price or walk away from the job.

From the field

A masonry contractor with about 15 employees had been winning plenty of work but never seemed to get ahead. The owner estimated from habit and gut feel, adding a rough overhead markup that had been the same for years. After building a simple worksheet tied to actual JobEx and OpEx percentages from the last 12 months of financials, the owner discovered that several of the bread-and-butter jobs were priced below what the business needed to stay solvent, let alone profitable. On the next round of bids, two jobs were repriced higher and one was declined. Revenue dipped slightly for about six weeks, but within a quarter the Profit account had more in it than it had seen in two years, and the owner stopped dreading payroll week.

Where people get it wrong

Many contractors treat the estimating worksheet as a cost-recovery tool: cover the job costs and add a standard markup and you’re done. The problem is that a standard markup based on industry averages or old habits may have nothing to do with what your specific business needs to stay profitable. Your CAPs come from your own numbers, not a benchmark table, and your bids need to reflect that.

In the book: Profit First for Commercial Construction, Chapter 5, Overhead Uncovered: A Cash Flow Perspective.

How do I price a job so it actually funds my allocations once it’s awarded?

The short answer

Pricing a job to fund your allocations starts before the bid: your price has to cover JobEx, OpEx, Owner’s Comp, Tax, and Profit at the percentages you’ve set, and it has to account for when cash will actually arrive, not just the contract total.

Why it’s different in construction

Construction cash doesn’t arrive in a lump: it comes through pay applications on a schedule set by the owner or GC, often with retainage withheld and approval cycles that add weeks to actual collection. A steel erection sub billing on a 30-day pay-app cycle, with retainage held on every pay app, may wait 60 to 90 days to see cash on work already performed. A bid that covers your costs on paper but ignores a 90-day collection cycle is like a fuel gauge that reads full at the pump but doesn’t account for the drive: you can run dry long before the money arrives. If your bid price doesn’t account for that timing gap, your allocations will run short even on a job you priced correctly on paper. Mapping your internal cutoff dates, submission deadlines, and expected payment timing to the customer’s billing cycle before you sign the contract is how you know whether the price actually works.

From the field

A steel erection sub with about 40 employees kept winning jobs and still running out of cash mid-project. When we dug into the numbers, the bids were covering materials and labor on paper, but the owner’s pay-app cycle ran 45 days and retainage was held until substantial completion, sometimes six months after the last bolt was set. The company was floating roughly $180,000 in unbilled or uncollected work at any given time, and that gap was quietly eating the margin. Once the owner started mapping the pay-app calendar before finalizing each bid (identifying exactly when cash would land and what carrying costs that created), he built those costs into the price or negotiated better payment terms upfront. Within two quarters, the mid-job cash crunches stopped, and allocations to Profit and Owner’s Comp started landing consistently.

From the book, Chapter 3, p. 51

“Is this that 10% overhead factor that we are supposed to add to our jobs?” Alex chimed in. “Roger, I don’t know what that number is supposed to be, but I don’t think it’s high enough.” “I can add up these expenses, but I still don’t know how to tell my contractors what to put in their bids,” Roger stated coldly. “How could I possibly know? My profit and loss statement gives me one figure, but that never seems to be enough.”

Profit First for Commercial Construction

In the book: Profit First for Commercial Construction, Chapter 5, Overhead Uncovered: A Cash Flow Perspective.

How can estimating prevent an unprofitable backlog?

The short answer

Estimating prevents an unprofitable backlog when you build each bid from realistic JobEx costs and verify that the resulting price leaves enough to cover OpEx and your POT allocations, and when you’re willing to change the scope, adjust terms, reprice, or walk away if it doesn’t. Accepting work that can’t support those numbers just fills your schedule with jobs that drain cash.

Why it’s different in construction

A concrete contractor with 40 people can book themselves solid six months out and still be losing ground if the bids were thin. The backlog looks healthy on paper while every pay app is quietly underfunding JobEx, leaving nothing for overhead and certainly nothing for profit. The discipline of checking each bid against your actual percentages (not industry averages, but your own numbers from your own books) catches that problem before the contract is signed, not after the job is half-built.

From the field

A concrete contractor with roughly 40 field employees had a full schedule and was still struggling to make payroll by the end of most months. When he mapped out his last eight completed jobs against his actual JobEx and OpEx figures, five of them had been bid below what his real costs required. He hadn’t been losing money on materials; he’d been underpricing the overhead burden each job needed to carry. Over the next bidding cycle he rebuilt his estimates using his own CAPs as a floor, declined two jobs that couldn’t support the right price, and picked up a smaller commercial pour at a margin that actually worked. Within two quarters his cash accounts stopped running on fumes.

From the book, Chapter 13, p. 199

I guess I learned that no matter how much revenue you’ve got, if you aren’t profitable, your business will ultimately crash down around you.” […] “Contractors had less work available, so I saw people taking jobs at lower prices just to keep their doors open. All of that extra competition led to everyone underbidding projects to try and get cash flowing and keep the doors open.”

Profit First for Commercial Construction

Where people get it wrong

A common trap is using industry benchmark percentages for overhead markup rather than your own numbers. Bidding from an industry average overhead rate is like every contractor in town using the same map to navigate their own neighborhood: it might get most of them close, but it won’t show you the dead end at the end of your street. Your OpEx percentage is specific to your company size, equipment, crew structure, and geography: an industry average can be off by enough to make a bid look profitable on paper while guaranteeing a shortfall in practice. Build your estimates from your own CAPs.

In the book: Profit First for Commercial Construction, Chapter 5, Overhead Uncovered: A Cash Flow Perspective.

How should I think about the fee on a cost-plus job?

The short answer

On a cost-plus job, the fee is not all profit: it must be large enough to cover your OpEx and leave a real POT after reimbursable job costs are paid, so price it from your actual company economics, not from a guess or an industry habit.

Why it’s different in construction

Cost-plus work is common in commercial construction, especially for steel erection subs and specialty trades where scope uncertainty is high. The trap is treating the fee as found money. In practice the fee is the only source of OpEx recovery and owner compensation on that job, so if you set it too low, the reimbursable costs get paid and you cover your overhead with nothing left over. Because reimbursable costs flow through JobEx and the fee funds OpEx and POT, you need to know your actual OpEx percentage and your target POT before you quote a fee number.

From the field

A steel erection sub with about 40 people had been pricing cost-plus work by adding a fee that felt competitive, roughly what he thought the market would bear. When he built out his CAPs for the first time, he discovered that his OpEx alone consumed most of that fee on a typical project, leaving almost nothing for owner compensation or profit. On a $1.2 million erection contract he had netted less than $15,000 after paying himself a below-market salary. He rebuilt his fee calculation starting from his real OpEx percentage and a target POT, then presented the new number to his two largest general contractors with a clear explanation of what it covered. Both accepted it. His next cost-plus project, at a similar size, produced enough POT to make a meaningful quarterly distribution for the first time.

Where people get it wrong

A common mistake is assuming that overhead is a standard percentage you add to the bid: the same number every contractor uses. As the book points out, overhead is unique to each business, and using someone else’s benchmark means you may be systematically underfunding your own OpEx on every cost-plus job you take.

In the book: Profit First for Commercial Construction, Chapter 5, Overhead Uncovered: A Cash Flow Perspective.

Ready to put this in place?

Go from Payroll Panic to Permanent Profit.