Home » The Profit First Construction Field Guide » Slow seasons, reserves and curveballs

Profit First for Construction FAQ

Slow seasons, reserves and curveballs

Slow seasons you can see coming and curveballs you can’t, and these answers cover having cash ready for both.

Related topics:Cash flow managementJob costing: JobEx and OpEx

How much cash reserve a contractor needs

What’s the right reserve level for a construction company with uneven cash flow?

The short answer

A good goal is to consistently build a buffer reserve over time, sized to your seasonality, backlog, debt load, receivables cycle, and equipment plans, never treated as a fixed gate. Build reserves from the Vault and retained quarterly profit, not from retainage.

Why it’s different in construction

Construction cash flow is lumpy by design: pay apps come in waves, retainage sits on the receivables side for months, and seasonal slowdowns can cut revenue sharply before overhead drops. A paving or site-work contractor facing a five-month winter slowdown needs a meaningfully different buffer than a year-round service contractor. Retainage ties up real dollars while owner pay, payroll, and OpEx still have to be funded, so track unreleased retainage in your AR aging and factor the expected release timing into your seasonal cash forecast, but never count it as cash already saved. When retainage delays create a meaningful financing cost, that’s a pricing conversation, not a reason to set a higher reserve percentage.

From the field

A husband-and-wife paving crew ran a tight shop: good work, loyal customers, and almost no cash left by February every year. They’d been telling themselves that the spring retainage releases would bail them out, so they never built a real buffer. One winter, two releases got pushed by sixty days each, and they were covering payroll on a credit card by March. After setting up Profit First for Construction, they started retaining half of their quarterly profit in the Vault instead of spending it down. Within three seasons they had built roughly six weeks of operating expenses in reserve, not a magic number, but enough to get through a slow February without touching the credit line. The retainage still came in late some years, but it no longer ran the business.

From the book, Chapter 14, p. 211

“Roger, did you figure you’d have extra profit when you bid the job?” Alex asked. “Well, no,” Roger replied. “ Pam, do you feel like you’ve built the reserves we need?” Alex asked. “We have some, but not enough,” Pam admitted. “Then there’s your answer,” Alex concluded. “How do I know how much of a reserve to aim for?” Pam asked. “I often help my clients set a goal related to what it takes to run their business. Perhaps you want two, three, or even four months’ worth of overhead in the bank. That can give you a strong sense of security.” “OK, I like that,” Pam said. “I will kick that around with Roger.

Profit First for Commercial Construction

Where people get it wrong

A common mistake is setting up a separate retainage reserve account, or automatically raising allocation percentages, to “hold” expected retainage. Neither is right. Treating retainage as a savings account is like counting the fish before you’ve pulled them out of the water: it’s still out there, and until it lands in your Income account it doesn’t belong in your reserve math. Retainage is a timing issue tracked in your AR aging, not a bank-account category. Once it’s collected, it goes into Income and is allocated at your normal percentages like any other deposit. Allocation percentages never change because of retainage.

In the book: Profit First for Commercial Construction, Chapter 10, System Maintenance: Quarterly Reviews and Timely Actions.

How should I estimate a seasonality reserve?

The short answer

Estimating a seasonality reserve starts with identifying your actual slow periods from two or three years of monthly revenue, then calculating the cash needed to cover payroll and essential operating expenses during those months, weighed against your receivables, backlog, debt, and working capital at the time.

Why it’s different in construction

Glass and glazing work, like many specialty trades, can swing hard with weather, school calendars, and commercial construction starts, meaning a 15-person shop may face two or three genuinely lean months where payroll keeps running but billings drop sharply. Retainage timing can make slow periods feel worse than they are: a chunk of AR may be sitting uncollected from prior jobs, which looks like a cushion on paper but isn’t cash in hand. The optional Drip account from Profit First for Construction is the right tool here: fund it during strong months and draw it down during slow ones, so the seasonal gap doesn’t force you into your Profit or Tax accounts or onto a line of credit.

From the field

For three straight winters, a glass and glazing contractor with 15 employees scrambled to make payroll in January and February. Revenue would drop by roughly $60,000 to $70,000 over those two months, but overhead kept running at full pace. Each year they’d pull from wherever they could find cash (sometimes Profit, sometimes a short draw on their credit line) and then spend the spring digging out. After reviewing three years of monthly bank statements, they identified the gap clearly: about $55,000 in operating expenses with minimal billings to offset it. They opened a Drip account and began setting aside a modest amount each month during the busy season. By the following winter they had about $40,000 in the Drip account going into the slow period, which wasn’t the full gap but cut the stress dramatically and eliminated the credit line draw entirely.

From the book, Chapter 11, p. 180

“Alex and I sat down with Roger and Pam recently to go over RGC’s cash flow,” I said. “To identify the seasonality patterns in his business, we started by pulling out the last five years of bank statements.” […] “We spread the statements out on the table,” Alex said, “and put the deposits and disbursements from the top of each bank statement into a simple spreadsheet.” […] “We saw a big drop in March, when there normally isn’t a lot going on,” Alex said. “It happened every year. Our workers’ comp renewal bill hits right at that time every year too.”

Profit First for Commercial Construction

Where people get it wrong

One piece of advice worth pushing back on: don’t treat retainage collections as the funding source for your seasonality reserve. Retainage is a timing issue tracked on the AR side, and when it comes in it goes through normal allocation like any other deposit. Building a reserve on the assumption that retainage will arrive in time for your slow season is planning on a schedule you don’t control.

In the book: Profit First for Commercial Construction, Chapter 11, Anticipating Seasonality: Planning for Predictable Cycles.

Should I keep separate reserves for seasonality and emergencies?

The short answer

Keeping separate accounts for predictable seasonal slowdowns and larger unexpected emergencies is a sound approach. When each account has a clear purpose, open it, and size both reserves around your actual seasonality, receivables, backlog, debt, and working-capital needs.

Why it’s different in construction

HVAC service and maintenance contractors face some of the sharpest seasonal swings in the trades: shoulder months between heating and cooling seasons can cut revenue by a third or more while payroll for close to 100 employees keeps running. A single pooled reserve gets spent down during the slow season and leaves nothing for a compressor failure or a fleet repair in the same month. Separating a predictable seasonal fund from a true emergency fund means you can plan the drip into each account throughout the year and still have a backstop when something unexpected hits.

From the field

An HVAC service and maintenance company with close to 100 employees had always managed seasonality by running the line of credit up in spring and paying it back in summer, year after year. When they mapped out their cash flow under Profit First for Construction, the owner realized the line of credit was never fully paid off before the next slow season began. They opened a Drip-style seasonality account and funded it steadily from OpEx through the busy months, and separately built a Vault for genuine emergencies. The first spring after the change, they didn’t touch the line of credit at all. When a service van needed a $9,000 transmission replacement in February, the Vault covered it without disrupting payroll or allocations. The owner described it as the first time in 12 years he wasn’t anxious in March.

From the book, Chapter 11, p. 183

“We talked previously about how to create Drip accounts,” I said, “and set aside funds specifically for those unexpected swings. You may also need to set aside funds for the ones you can see coming.” […] “Is it as easy as looking at last year, evaluating what might be different this year, and shooting for saving that amount?” Alex asked. “Pretty much,” I said. “Again, you may not cover the entire shortfall, especially in the first year, but you can lessen the impact. After that it gets easier.”

Profit First for Commercial Construction

Where people get it wrong

A common mistake is treating one pooled “rainy-day fund” as both a seasonal buffer and an emergency reserve. When a slow season drains it, there’s nothing left for a real emergency, and the temptation to borrow from Profit or Tax accounts follows quickly. Keeping the two purposes in separate accounts makes it much harder to accidentally spend your emergency fund on a predictable slow month you could have planned for.

In the book: Profit First for Commercial Construction, Chapter 11, Anticipating Seasonality: Planning for Predictable Cycles.

Can I use my emergency fund to cover a slow season in winter?

The short answer

Predictable seasonal slowdowns are best handled with a dedicated seasonal buffer, funded during stronger months, so your emergency reserve stays available for genuine surprises; if a winter slowdown turns out materially worse than expected, cover the gap from whatever reserves you have and then revise your seasonal plan.

Why it’s different in construction

Mechanical and HVAC contractors feel this acutely: new-construction work slows in winter while service calls spike, and the cash timing rarely lines up with payroll. The better move is to recognize your seasonal pattern from last year’s numbers, estimate the shortfall, and drip funds into a seasonal buffer account during your busy months. That way you’re not raiding emergency money for a slowdown you could see coming. If the slowdown is worse than forecast, diagnose why before deciding whether it’s a one-time variance or a sign that your allocations or pricing need adjusting.

From the field

An HVAC and mechanical contractor with about 60 employees had been through the same winter cash crunch three years running. Each January they dipped into whatever reserves they had, told themselves they’d rebuild in spring, and never quite did. When they mapped out their last two years of revenue by month, the pattern was obvious: roughly the same dip, same timing, every year. They set up a simple seasonal buffer account and started moving a small fixed amount into it every week from May through October. The first winter they used it, they covered six weeks of the gap without touching their emergency reserve. By the second year the buffer was large enough that January felt almost normal, and their emergency fund stayed intact for a genuine surprise: a compressor failure on a service vehicle that needed immediate replacement.

From the book, Chapter 9, p. 150

“What else? When do you typically run out of money in this business?” I asked. “These winter months kill me,” Peter said. “I know,” I said. “You might consider a Drip account, as I mentioned before, to prepare for seasonality. It’s a great way to manage cash flow during slow periods so you can make sure your employees are paid, stay current on note payments, and keep the lights on.

Profit First for Commercial Construction

In the book: Profit First for Commercial Construction, Chapter 11, Anticipating Seasonality: Planning for Predictable Cycles.

Planning for slow seasons

What should I do if I need a line of credit every slow season?

The short answer

Recurring seasonal borrowing is a signal that your cash cycle needs attention, not a normal cost of doing business: review your pricing, billing timing, overhead, and whether you have a seasonal reserve built into your system. A line of credit should be a last resort for short timing gaps, not a predictable annual crutch.

Why it’s different in construction

Construction cash flow is inherently lumpy: pay apps come in waves, crews and equipment costs run through slow months regardless of revenue, and some trades go nearly dark for weeks at a time. A low-voltage or security contractor, for example, may see commercial project starts slow in winter while overhead keeps running. The fix isn’t a bigger credit line: it’s identifying the seasonal pattern early and dripping cash into a reserve account throughout the year so the slow months are funded before they arrive.

From the field

A second-generation low-voltage and security contractor had been drawing on their line of credit every January and February for as long as anyone could remember. It felt normal, just part of running the business. When they mapped out their cash flow month by month, they realized they were spending the line down by about $40,000 each winter and spending the first half of spring paying it back, with interest. Once they set up a Drip account and started moving a small amount from OpEx into it every allocation cycle starting in July, they had roughly $35,000 sitting ready by December. The next winter they never touched the line of credit, and by the following year the owner said it felt like getting a raise.

From the book, Chapter 5, p. 89

These guys were desperately trying to keep people employed and gear up for the big high school job. They were the squirrels who hadn’t gathered enough acorns for the winter. The financial circumstances for many were so tight that they had to take out pay-by-the-week loans to cover expenses.

Profit First for Commercial Construction

Where people get it wrong

A common piece of bad advice is to treat a seasonal line of credit as a permanent working-capital tool: essentially running it as a second operating account that resets every year. That approach hides a real pricing or overhead problem and keeps you paying interest on money you should have set aside yourself. A line of credit is for short, unpredictable timing gaps; if you can predict the gap to the month, you can fund it yourself.

In the book: Profit First for Commercial Construction, Chapter 11, Anticipating Seasonality: Planning for Predictable Cycles.

How should I prepare for predictable seasonal cash gaps?

The short answer

Contractors with predictable slow seasons should build a cash reserve during busy periods, sized from their own cash-flow history, backlog, payroll commitments, debt load, and risk tolerance. A good goal is to build that buffer consistently over time, and a separate account can help you see and protect those funds.

Why it’s different in construction

Steel erection work is among the most weather-dependent trades: crane picks stop in high wind, ice, and extreme cold, and project owners often push steel packages to spring starts, which compresses the busy season and leaves a hard gap in late fall and winter. A crew of 15 means payroll keeps running even when billable days don’t, and equipment costs (insurance, payments, storage) don’t pause either. Think of it the way a bear approaches winter: you fatten up during the season when the food is there, so you’re not scrambling when it isn’t, except a bear doesn’t have the option of taking out a line of credit in February. Planning the reserve during the summer billing peak, rather than scrambling for a line of credit in January, is what separates contractors who thrive through slow periods from those who just survive them.

From the field

Every October, a steel erection sub with about 15 employees hit the same wall: work slowed, but payroll, insurance, and equipment costs didn’t. For three straight years the owner had bridged the gap with a line of credit, telling himself he’d pay it down once spring work picked up, and he did, but barely, before drawing on it again the following fall. After mapping out the cash-flow pattern month by month, it was clear the slow period ran roughly 14 to 16 weeks and cost about $40,000 in operating expenses beyond what came in. He opened a separate account and began moving a set dollar amount into it each week during the April-through-September busy season, drawing from the Vault and from the profit he retained at each quarterly split, not from operating cash flow. By the following October he had about $35,000 set aside, covered the slow period without touching the line of credit, and kept his Profit and Tax accounts intact. The line of credit stayed at zero through the winter for the first time in years.

From the book, Chapter 16, p. 239

“With concrete, there’s always a slow season,” Mark went on. “We used to just hope we’d make it through. Now, I’ve got cash set aside for the slow months. No more stressing come winter—we’ve got a cushion, and I know I can survive.”

Profit First for Commercial Construction

Where people get it wrong

Some contractors assume the right move is to raise their Owner’s Comp or Profit allocation during the busy season to “bank” extra cash in those accounts, then draw it down in winter. That distorts the system and makes it hard to know whether you’re actually profitable. The cleaner approach is a dedicated reserve account funded steadily during peak months: it keeps your allocations honest and makes the seasonal cushion visible and protected.

In the book: Profit First for Commercial Construction, Chapter 11, Anticipating Seasonality: Planning for Predictable Cycles.

Cash emergencies and surprise costs

If retainage delays my cash flow, how do I protect tax funding?

The short answer

Retainage is a timing and working-capital issue, not a reason to change your allocation percentages or open a separate retainage account. Keep allocating every dollar that comes in, including collected retainage, at your normal percentages, and build reserves over time so a slow retainage release doesn’t leave your Tax account short.

Why it’s different in construction

On commercial and public work, retainage can sit out there for months or even a year, and a plumbing or mechanical contractor with 40 people can have a significant slice of earned revenue locked up at any given time. That gap is real, but the fix is in your bid price and your reserve-building habits, not in adjusting your Tax or Profit percentages. If the financing cost of waiting on retainage is material, factor it into what you charge for the work. Once that retainage check finally arrives, it goes into Income and gets allocated just like any other deposit: no exceptions.

From the field

A plumbing contractor with about 40 people was doing mostly commercial tenant-finish work, where retainage of around 10% was standard on every job. When a cluster of projects finished within the same quarter, roughly $180,000 in retainage came in over about six weeks. The owner had been mentally earmarking that money for taxes, but because it wasn’t sitting in the Tax account, he’d been raiding OpEx to cover quarterly estimates and falling behind on payroll reserves. After setting up Profit First for Construction, he started allocating every deposit, including retainage checks, at his normal percentages the day the money hit Income. Within two quarters his Tax account had a real balance for the first time, and he stopped dreading estimated tax due dates. The key shift was treating retainage as ordinary revenue when collected, not as a special windfall to manage separately.

Where people get it wrong

A common piece of bad advice is to open a dedicated retainage reserve account and hold those funds separately until the project closes out. Opening a retainage reserve account is like taping a “do not touch” sign to a jar of cash on your desk: the sign doesn’t actually hold the money, it just adds a step while the real problem, a bid price that doesn’t account for the financing cost of waiting, goes unsolved. Retainage is an accounts-receivable timing issue; track it on your AR aging, and once it’s collected, run it through your normal allocation like any other payment.

In the book: Profit First for Commercial Construction, Chapter 14, Growing Wisely: Balancing Expansion with Cash Stability.

Can I use my Profit or Tax account during a payroll crisis?

The short answer

Profit First for Construction allows tapping the Profit or Tax account as a last resort in a genuine emergency like a payroll shortfall, but only after reserves are exhausted and only with a clear repayment plan, so a one-time crisis doesn’t quietly become a habit.

Why it’s different in construction

Electrical contractors and other trade contractors with hourly crews face a hard deadline every week: payroll has to clear. When a pay app is delayed or a customer is slow, that deadline doesn’t move. That pressure makes the Profit or Tax account look like an easy fix. The Profit First framework acknowledges this reality (it doesn’t pretend emergencies don’t happen), but it insists on a specific order: tap reserves first, then Profit or Tax only if reserves are gone, and document how you’ll replenish. A separate Payroll account, if you have one, also acts as an early warning so you see the shortfall coming days before Friday rather than hours before.

From the field

An electrical contractor with eight employees hit a rough patch when a commercial client delayed a $60,000 pay app by six weeks. Payroll was $18,000 every two weeks, and the Vault was nearly empty from a slow winter. Rather than putting the payroll on a line of credit, the owner followed the framework: he documented the shortfall, confirmed it was a timing issue rather than a systemic problem, and moved $18,000 from the Profit account with a written plan to replenish it from the next two pay-app deposits. The pay app came in five weeks later, he replenished the Profit account first before spending anything discretionary, and the system stayed intact. The experience also pushed him to build a larger buffer over the following two quarters so the next delay wouldn’t reach the Profit account at all.

From the book, Chapter 12, pp. 190 to 191

“So, Mark, how did you handle your shortfall?” I asked. “Yeah, like I told you, I had to raid my Profit and Tax accounts to cover it,” Mark admitted. “And Elvis? What did you do?” I asked. “I had to pull money from my own pocket because I didn’t want to be the weak link in the group,” Elvis said, slightly embarrassed. “What else could I do? […] “It was definitely good that I had it to use,” Mark said. “I’m glad I did because otherwise, I would’ve had to take out one of those pay-by-the-week loans that cost so much in interest.

Profit First for Commercial Construction

Where people get it wrong

The mistake most contractors make is treating the Profit account like a general backup fund: dipping into it whenever cash feels tight without asking whether it’s a real emergency or just poor timing. That turns a safety valve into a revolving door, and the Profit account never actually builds. The rule is clear: reserves first, Profit and Tax only as a last resort, and always with a repayment plan.

In the book: Profit First for Commercial Construction, Chapter 12, Managing Curveballs: Navigating Cash Flow Disruptions.

What if my quarterly tax payment comes due and I don’t have enough in the Tax account?

The short answer

When the Tax account comes up short at payment time, the first job is to figure out why (underfunded allocations, a profitability problem, pricing that doesn’t support your targets, JobEx overruns, or a tax estimate that was simply too low) and then work with your tax adviser on the actual obligation and any available payment options before touching other accounts.

Why it’s different in construction

Paving and other seasonal trades can go long stretches with little revenue coming in, then get hit with a tax bill right as the busy season is ramping back up and cash is already stretched across payroll and materials. If your Tax allocation percentage was set during a slow period when income looked modest, a strong finish to the year can leave you underfunded relative to the actual liability. That’s why the quarterly review matters: as the book notes, if you’re watching your cash through the year, you can catch early signs that your tax set-aside needs to be higher before you’re scrambling in April.

From the field

A husband-and-wife paving operation with a small crew had been in business for about eight years and had never once had enough in the bank when quarterly estimates came due. They’d been pulling from wherever they could find cash: sometimes the account meant for materials, sometimes a credit card. When we set up their accounts and ran the numbers, it turned out their Tax allocation had been set based on a rough guess rather than an actual estimate from their accountant. We got the real number, adjusted the allocation, and set up a simple quarterly check-in with their tax preparer. The first year they ran the full system, their September estimated payment was covered with about $3,000 to spare: small, but it was the first time in years they hadn’t had to scramble.

In the book: Profit First for Commercial Construction, Chapter 10, System Maintenance: Quarterly Reviews and Timely Actions.

How should I respond when material costs spike mid-project?

The short answer

A mid-project material cost spike is a job-level problem to solve at the job level: pursue change orders, tighten purchasing, and update pricing for future bids. Do not change your Profit First allocation percentages mid-quarter in response; hold the current percentages through the quarter and revisit any adjustment at the quarterly review.

Why it’s different in construction

Roofing, paving, and other material-intensive trades are especially exposed to sudden price swings in asphalt, lumber, or steel. When costs jump on a job already under contract, the immediate moves are operational: document the cost increase, submit a change order if the contract allows it, and control purchasing on everything still uncommitted. The Profit First system is not the lever to pull here: your allocation percentages reflect your business model over time, not the cost structure of one job. If spikes are becoming a pattern, that’s a pricing and estimating conversation to have at quarter-end, not a reason to reshuffle percentages in the middle of the quarter.

From the field

Midway through a commercial re-roofing job, a roofing contractor with about eight employees watched membrane prices jump roughly 18 percent due to a supply disruption. The owner’s first instinct was to pull money from the Profit account to cover the overrun and adjust his JobEx percentage upward right away. Instead, he held his allocations steady, submitted a change-order request to the building owner, and tightened purchasing on the remaining materials. The change order covered about half the overage. At the next quarterly review he looked at his actual JobEx numbers across all jobs for the quarter, confirmed the spike was not isolated, and made a modest upward adjustment to his JobEx percentage going forward. His Profit account stayed intact, and he had a documented basis for the pricing change rather than a reactive mid-quarter guess.

From the book, Chapter 12, p. 189

“The cost of my materials has gone through the roof,” he said. “I’ve been trying to keep us under budget, but when suppliers keep jacking up prices, it’s a losing battle. Anyway, I had a bunch of bills hit and we didn’t get much money in this month. My suppliers were going to withhold a shipment.” “OK, everybody,” I said. “I know the timing of bills can suck. Unexpected expenses will come up, no matter how well you prepare. The key is to not let it wreck your system.”

Profit First for Commercial Construction

Where people get it wrong

A common bad move is treating a cost spike as a reason to immediately raise the JobEx allocation percentage or lower the Profit target mid-quarter. One bad stretch of two or three weeks is not a systemic problem: it may be seasonal, job-specific, or a one-time market event. Changing percentages mid-quarter based on a short-term hit undermines the stability the system is designed to create; wait for the quarterly review, check whether the pattern is real, and adjust then if the numbers support it.

In the book: Profit First for Commercial Construction, Chapter 12, Managing Curveballs: Navigating Cash Flow Disruptions.

Ready to put this in place?

Go from Payroll Panic to Permanent Profit.